Jonah Goldberg Compares VA Pamphlet to Nazi Eugenics

You can view this video right here by getting the latest version of Flash Player!
DOWNLOADS: (1231)
Download WMV Download Quicktime
PLAYS: (1683)
Play WMV Play Quicktime

August 24, 2009 News Corp

From TPM:

Jonah Goldberg, editor-at-large of National Review Online, went on Fox News today to fan the flames of the latest fabricated "death panel" controversy.

Goldberg equated a Veterans Affairs pamphlet -- one that's reportedly no longer being used -- with Nazi eugenics, saying "death panels may not be too far off the horizon."

The pamphlet in question is one that, Fox reported this weekend, encourages disabled veterans to decide whether their lives are worth living. Tammy Duckworth, an assistant secretary of the VA, told Fox on Sunday that the department instructed VA doctors to stop using the pamphlet in 2007.

But Fox has ignored that insistence, saying soldiers returning from Iraq are given the pamphlet.

Dave N.: This really points out just how profoundly dishonest Jonah Goldberg is, just as he was with trying to deny that James Von Brunn was a right-wing extremist. These remarks are an outgrowth of his specious "Liberal Fascism" thesis, which since President Obama's election he has framed as the apotheosis of Obama's own fascist tendencies.

But as noted above, Tammy Duckworth has pointed out that the pamphlet in question was commissioned by the Bush administration, and discontinued in 2007. The Obama administration has had nothing to do with this.



Login or Register to post comments.

142 comments

another Nazi toting jew... whats new?

/puke

That doughy pantload would rat out his fellow jews and send them to the ovens in a heartbeat.

with this shit, jonah, like all the reichwingnuts,
you can not enlighten stupid...they refuse
rational thought.

)O(

This idiot claims liberals won't accept his Jewishness, or accuses them of anti-semitism, when they ridicule his gibberish. Actually it's Jews who won't recognize him as one of them.

To be born Jewish, your mother has to be Jewish. Ideally you're father would be too, but if the marriage is mixed, it's through the mother. Otherwise you have to convert. The Orthodox in particularly make that conversion difficult.

lucianne goldberg is not Jewish.

Interesting that you capitalize "Nazi, but not "jew" Maybe I'm a little too sensitive.

Maybe the implication is Goldberg is more nazi than jewish?

That book is online here:
http://www.rihlp.org/pubs/Your_life_your_choi...

Make up your own mind.

Really, just

/facepalm

The hilarious thing is that most of my more conservative relatives have strong Living Wills. Many worked in health care and know what can happen if you don't, many are vets (a few are both).

The veterans that buy into this Republican crap are the ones that have always loved the GOP because of its militarism.

They hang out at the VFW and the American Legion.

I'm a vet. I'm a proud Dem because I happen to know what the Dems have done consistently to help veterans. As opposed to the GOP.

And have never lost a personal debate with a Republican veteran over which party really cares about them.

This is like the stupid seniors who would ever believe Republicans or talk radio about which party has a history of putting on the line for seniors.

Stupid veterans, stupid Seniors, stupid Americans.

And nothing "patriotic" in the whole bunch of right-wing liars that they rely on.

Not a one of them has an ounce of honesty, or integrity, or shame!

Jonah Goldberg: liar, idiot, or lying idiot?

Yes

.

How about idiot frgn' liar?

Chandler's evil twin.

Send that chickenshit combat dodging Doughy Pantload to the front lines in Iraq. Duckworth lost 2 limbs fighting for her county. Whatever the fuck Doughy Pantload and that bleached blonde Faux News bimbo shill got to say on this subject is irrelevant. What have they sacrificed for their country?

"Megyn" Kelly? Is that how conservative elitists spell "Megan" these days?

"Megyn" looks like a pear sitting on that stool btw. Rupert is feeding her well.

You ever see that supposed "news" show she and John Boy Walton have in the morning, called "America's Newsroom?" They ALWAYS inject their viewpoint into news stories. So, she certainly lives up to the "we report, you decide" crap.

I'm still trying to figure out which pamphlet they are reading.

These lying Reslug morons get even more ridiculous everyday with their imaginary Nazi loving fantacies.

What can you say. Republicans seem absolutely obsessed with homosexuals, Nazis and presidential penises.

Obama's caving into Republicans on health care, Republicans have become babbling idiots (well, nothing knew there I guess), carrying loaded machine guns is considered a reasonable debate tactic, and liberals are now Nazis because Fox says so. The world has gone to hell.

AND I AM GOING TO BURNING MAN!!!

They have a REAL teabagging camp there... I'm going to go out front and yell "Get yer damn Gubberminnt hands of my Medicare!" while scrota are delicately balanced on foreheads. Meanwhile, the world is in your care-- don't break it any more than it already is.

Use plenty of SPF 50!

You know why we should respect Jonah's opinion?
Because his mommy made sure that we all found out about Monica's dress.
Now them's credentials. Give him his own show. A real expert.

Who takes this guy seriously besides the right wing militia who are looking for an excuse?

Really I don't think anybody listens to this guy. He is a joke. Does he apear anyplace else besides Cluster Faux?

The problem is, every conservative hack out there is pushing something bad about Obama. The more people here the crap, no matter where it's coming from, the more will believe it.

Pass your Bills and then go defend them. It can be done.

Who cares about what the wacko elements - even if they're half the population think. I'll still like our odds at election time.

evidently sarah palin listened....
who knows that her poor baby is not
the product of her and jonah's
illicit fornication? sarah appears to
enjoy out of marriage affairs?

These shills call us unpatriotic because we didn't support the previous commander-in-chief when he started this illegal war that is needlessly sacrificing our men and women and countless civilians. They support the war as long as they or their children are not fighting it.

We should start calling this guy Jonah Goebbels. He's constantly spreading nazi, I mean conservative, propaganda.

Has a ring to it. Hope your suggestion goes viral.

These obstructionists are hurting people who would like to plan for their future. What the fuck is their point? It is simply idiotic to not let people know what their options are if they get really really sick and decisions need to be made. Isn't it a good idea to let people know what you want them to do in certain situations?

Be it the town hall tea baggers, be it the gun nuts, be it the defenders of torture in the name of "national security"...boy, the current Republican party would have no problem lining up a whole bunch of volunteers for time travel back to Germany in the 30s.

More recruits for the Gestapo.

OMG

Here we go again. I just got done saying on that Fox News video clip that this pamphlet, if one bothers to look at the first couple pages at the VA website is in the process of being revised and should be out soon the VA said. Everything Goldberg is saying could change tomorrow morning for all we know.

Next, I've filled out this questionaire and so have other former military members of my family. All it does is give various scenarios that every person could face later on in life. It goes into the different procedures for different medical situations and what happens if you decide not to have those prodedures. Furthermore, the pamphlet provides various ways for the veteran to decide at some later time if they choose how they would like their loved ones to handle thier situation if they happen to become incompaciated at some point.

There is nothing eugenic about it. I don't know about anyone else, but I for one would like to know that members of my family know of my wishes and what I would like for them to do if I happen to become incompaciated at some point. It sure beats the moment where I am incompacitated and cannot decide and a doctor asks my relatives: "What do you want done?" My relatives answer, "I don't know. Joe never said. Lets flip a coin."

Joe, thank you for your service to our country.

I really think you should form a group to help combat this nonsense. Maybe you should just try to get onto Fox and other networks to help combat this nonsense. I'm serious....there's so much crap being spewed by the right that we need real life examples from people like you to help flush that crap down the toilet.

Just a thought....

Flipping a coin would be faster than having some Republican come down and start up a political debate about your rights as a brain dead vegetable. You should put the "flip a coin" thing in your will: Heads: you pull the plug. Tails: you pull the plug. It'll make the choice so much easier now that it's all up to chance.

He is not wearing a flag on his lapel. He hates America.

and Mr. Goldberg lost.

next....

.

I have written this countless times, and with the success of the Color of Change boycott of Mr. Glenn "cries more than Meryl Streep" Beck, I truly think it is about time we all got together and took real action. The only reason FoxNews has ANY legitimacy is because Obama and the Dems GIVE IT LEGITIMACY. Every time a Dem appears on Fox, and every time Obama or Gibbs or any other White House denizen calls on a Fox "reporter", they make them look like a real news network. Well, it's time to starve them out. Kick them out of the press room, along with all others working for Murdoch's media empire (there is nothing illegal about this, nor is it against anyones First Amendment rights). Since they do not have any intention of reporting fairly on anything concerning the Obama administration, and their recent VA "death panel" tactics show how low they will go with their lying, they do not deserve to be in the press room. And Obama and the heads of the Democratic Party should make it clear to EVERY Dem Senator and Rep - you appear on FoxNews or give interviews to ANY murdoch publication, you will be persona non gratis to the White House and to the Democratic Party. This has gone on long enough. Liars must be made to pay for thier unfounded attacks on our President and on our party. Time to starve the beast, and feast on the remains.

DOJ to investigate FOX for defrauding the public under wire, radio and TV fraud provisions of the RICO Act and direct the FCC to suspend all of News Corps' radio, TV and cable licenses and franchises while the invesitgations take place. Murdoch and his senior peopleneed to be named as persons of interest in the investigation. Fidings of fraud need to be punished to the maximum extent under the criminal provisions of RICO. concurrently, they need to be investigated for incitement to violence, riot and insurrection.

It's time to put this anti-American Propganda organ down, for the good and safety of the country. It is a hostile foreign operation.

........he should direct SOMEONE to do SOMETHING, because whatever it is he is doing surely isn't working too well. I'm not so sure he has it in him to do it........and the ones "directing Obama" might just like the way things are going.

This is all you have to know about Goldberg:
"As for why my sorry as* isn't in the kill zone,lots of people think this is a searingly pertinent question. No answer could I give -- I'm 35 years old, my family couldn't afford the lost income,I have a baby daughter, my as* is, er,sorry, are a few -- ever seem to suffice. But this is chickenhawk nonsense is something that's that's been batted around too many times to get into again here."

...Courtesy of FOX Propaganda. The Doughy Pantload, Cheetoh-becrumbed-fingers douchebag speaks again. I was wondering when this asshat would weigh in with his latest ignorant spewings.

I do believe his mama was the one who suggested to Linda Tripp that she turn over any tapes of conversations with Lewinski......wonder why she was never called to testify?........hmmmmmmmm......I believe his mama was also named a "spy" for the Nixon administration to find out if the "other side" was having any affairs or whatever other sleazy info she could produce.........Guess that apple doesn't fall far from the tree after all.....

lovely family there, eh???.......:)

the Bush administration, but aren't all the bureaucrats and apparachiks in the Obama administration from the same foundation funded think tanks and policy institutes as those from the Bush administration?

)O(

Apparatchiks is primarily a term used for Communist bureaucrats.

Communist Russia was our ally in World War II, Nazi Germany our common enemy.

And using both the terms bureaucrat and apparatchik in the same sentence is redundant.

the 'left' and the 'right' are two sides of the same coin, and it's just a phoney paradigm that the powers that be push everyone into one camp or the other, but they are really the same, they just give you the illusion of difference with phoney wedge issues like gay marriage and flag burning?

... yeah, you are right, standing for equality, human rights and dignity, peace, social consciousness, freedom, scientific advancement, etc. is exactly the same from an ideological stand point than the "f*ck you I got mine" conservative thought.

Furthermore, the left in this country is minimal, so indeed it makes complete sense to blame it as being equally guilty of the clusterf*ck that conservatives have brought to bear in the 3+ decades they have been in power.

is that the Obama administration that stands for human rights, peace, and freedom, and 'social concscousness'? I could have sworn they were continuing the exact same policies of the bush administration in these areas.

Obama killed the Global Gag Rule from almost day 1.

the Left. Under any normal consideration, this is a center-right administration.

But having to recognize that would sorta kinda make the false dichotomy you were trying to parade kind of silly, right?

If that's the case you would be accusing the right of fascist tendencies, but instead you exclusively use the unhistorical accusation against the Left.

Now as explained before the Extreme Left Is Communism, the Extreme Right Fascism (which includes both Mussolini who defined the term, and the Nazis.)

However the end result probably feels similar to the people caught in the middle, but then the terms are authoritarianism, and totalitarianism.

Communism would put the government in charge of business, Fascism would put business in charge of the government. Communism is like one store owned by the government, Fascism like multiple stores and/or unregulated monopolies ordering the government. The only difference was in both they have political criminal statutes that are of no great concern to the vested interests, only the governments.

What throws in the monkey wrench is Communist, Fascists, and Capitalists in war-time seek to fill war-time interests, although for the latter two, it's generally very profitable to do so, making them in a sense collaberaters.

the left uses facts, questions authority, doesn't take things at face value, does not like to be manipulated by false calls to patriotism, does not blindly follow their leaders, and prefers the truth to propaganda.

the right hates facts, follows authority, takes everything at face value, loves to be manipulated especially through false calls to patriotism, blindly follows their leaders, and loves propaganda rather than the truth.

you are so smart and so right, they are exactly the same.

What a hack...He can't find or research or spend the time necessary to ever do any real news or journalism but plenty of time to let Beck and Hannity feed him bags of garbage so he can make up his next bottle of swill..

My Dad a soon to be 80 year old veteran, ex-pow, loves the health care he recieves from the VA. This idiot chicken hawk doesn't have the first clue about Veteran's health much less veterans in general considering he is a chicken hawk who would no more defend his coubtry than cut off his little pee pee. Assholes like this fool just piss me and my Dad off!

peace

continued the Bush policies of war in Iraq and Afghanistan, warrantless wiretapping, rendition, secrecy, dishonesty, loss of civil rights, liberty and freedom in the name of keeping us safe from 'the terrorists', he even kept Bush's defense secretary, it's a good thing Rummy wasn't still there or we would still be stuck with him. How's that for change you can beleive in!

If Jonah knew how to use the "internets" he might be able to simply google Bush + eugenics and find out that the Bush family has been involved in eugenics for many years. Might shut up some of these "morans". This is very well documented. Here is a good start http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/arti...

Holdren is also very heavily into, and a proponent of eugenics. I kind of seems like a continuity from one administration to the other, with no differences in the policies that really matter, just differences on wedge issues.

LOL

that is some nice trolling you got there.

The Nationalist Socialist Party( Nazis) were an extreme right wing party.
Please do look into this. It will help you understand history a little better.
In the meantime, It's better to keep ones mouth shut and be thought an idiot, than it is to open it and remove all doubt.
have a nice day.

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
Oh,

And have a nice day.

that really made it clear that Nazism was a bunch of left-wing extremists, into eugenics and collectivism just like the current administration in the USA.

Tell me something, How long have you been trolling? Is this your first time out?
We've had teenagers come here who are more intellectual than you.

Buh Bye.

)O(

You're confusing socialism the economic model with socialism the political model, which is the state as the center of society and power trickling down if at all (so to speak), as apposed to a democratic society, with power trickling up from the people.

but all I see is your neck disappearing into the back of your pants.

"left-wing extremist"? Wasn't that what the National Socialist (Nazi) party was?

.

John Holdren is not a eugenicist? He doesn't promote forced sterilization and abortion to combat 'overpopulation'? He didn't write that this would be acceptable under the constituition? He didn't advocate adding birth control and/or sterilization drugs surreptitiously to drinking water? I thought he did, I thought he wrote that in his book "Ecoscience, Population, Resources, and Environment".

eugenicist named John Holdren who is the science czar for the Obama administration?

... LOL.

Great fun though...

would think there was such a thing as a eugenicist named John Holdren, who is the science czar for the Obama administration. But anybody who researched it probably would beleive that there was.

LOL!

)O(

The subject of the thread is fictitious death panels, not misquoted scientists.

If trolls can see so much threat in reforming the medical system to be more efficient and cost controlled, they can see threats in Dr. Seuss.

to begin with. But keep digging...

LOL^2

but there is some other guy named John Holdren who is the head of the Office of Science and Technology in the Obama administration, who wrote a book called 'Ecoscience, Population, Resources, and Enviroment', where he promoted eugenics policies.

... you are almost there, a couple more shovel loads and you're in China.

LOL^4

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]

LOL^16

Yes, I have read the book. Now, are you disputing the things that I have written that he said in the book? In between your juvenile attacks on me, I couldn't figure out if you were disputing it or not, because you won't address what he wrote in his book, you just want to attack me.

he makes those claims, with their full context?

LOL^256

)O(

They know it's virtually impossible to read an entire book in the lifespan of a typical thread.

Even if something appeared in a book out of context it can mean the exact opposite. I remember reading a book called the Biological Time Bomb that predicted all kinds of things that could happen in science and technology, both utopia and dystopia. One could take the dystopic views out of context and say the writer was advocating the practice.

One could probably do the same thing to Thomas Malthus An Essay on the Principals of Population.

)O(

Since the book was published 32 years ago, and now costs 200 dollars or more, I suspect you haven't read it either, but are quoting quoters of quoters.

At one time putting flouride in the water was considered a communist plot.

)O(

Tue, 08/25/2009 - 17:32 — stacy41

There's no such thing as an office of the Science Czar.

And since when were Czars either Nazis, and or Communists?

)O(

So was the Union of Soviet Social Republics and the Republic of China Republicans?

Over $200 used on Amazon. Published in 1977.

is such an ass that it defies description.

is a troll.

anything that does not correspond with their preconceived ideas.

Jonah Goldberg is the son of Mrs. Goldberg,the infamous co-conspirator who tried her hand to embroil Bill Clinton into scandal
and impeachment.What a lovely family-so patriotic.!!Why Jonah and
his ilk always refers to the Nazis as the epitome of "evil" is beyond me.How about the Stalinists,Soviets,Gulags,GPU,NKWD,and KGB
for a change?? Thank heaven for the remoteness of Siberia where most
of the gulags(concentration camps)were located--nobody knew.HaHa!!!
OF course the US allied herself with a mass murderer named Uncle Joe,who actually killed people himself.But,what the heck-we can't be
so picky,can we?????Such a sweet and noble man,loved his mustache.
suc

The same corporate and banking elites that control America allied with Uncle Joe, the leader of the communist movement that was created and funded by themselves.

)O(

Actually corporate interests allied with the Nazis. Ford built much of the army trucks and cars of the Nazi army, although leaders continued to drive BMW's and Mercedes.

preston boosh actually had a bank taken from his directorship by the US government for dealing with the enemy.

And a virtual who's who, of corporate interests tried to over throw FDR in 1933 and replace him with a fascist dictatorship fashioned much like the Nazis. But using disgruntled former soldiers like the French fascist group the Crux Feu.

Was it the same corporate interests that backed and controlled bush sr. and jr., and are now backing and controlling Obama?

)O(

But the AMA, the pharmaceutical corporations and the insurance corporations are deluding and frightening people to go out and disrupt town hall meetings, not engage in them, since they stand to lose tons of money if real reform happens.

And although most corporations send money to both sides to feather their beds, these aforementioned companies tend to send the bulk of their money to republican candidates.

)O(

who contributed the most of the trucks for the nazi war effort. Ford did help, in fact I think he got a medal of merit from the nazi government. Ford was personally opposed to the intervention of the US in WWII, since he was an open fascist sympathizer.

Bush's granddad was "Prescott" in fact the Bush family had their assets seized for being accused of collaboration with the enemy. Rumor has it, that the only reason why Bush Sr. joined the Navy was as a move to clear his family's name. Furthermore, Prescott Bush was one of the alleged masterminds behind the business plot to overthrow FDR in the 30s.

)O(

Supposedly Ford also sent Hitler a personal cheque regularly on his birthday as a present for $10,000.00.

I can't remember, but who was that major American designer, who designed the Nazi uniforms, Bill Blass?

I see that you're trying to educate someone. Good luck with that.

)O(

You're right about the Prescott, but I'm tired, and just returned from the VA hospital.

I was getting Prescott confused with:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KsKpevcZfHM

What did we ever do to deserve that Ys ?
It really is something else. The apple doesn't fall far from the tree does it?

so that is the dunce the Bushes are going to unleash on our country in 2 more elections?

$2 says he suffers hemophilia.

)O(

Actually, now that I think of it GM were among the corporations trying to overthrow FDR in 1933, along with Standard Oil, Swanson Frozen Foods, and the Morgan Stanley group (or an earlier incarnation).

Geezz, read a history book.

)O(

Mamamountin in Texas.

)O(

No surprise boosh created a death panel law for veterans:

http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/HS...

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
)O(

I disagree all the time, and people here generally don't accuse me of being a troll.

For one thing, I support my arguments point-by-point rather than by broadsides.

And your arguments lack so much weight, your broadsides are like a DQ cup in an updraft hitting a speeding SUV's door.

... not their own facts.

I betcha our little troll thought his math teacher was trying to squash his freedom of expression when he kept on telling him that "2+2=5" ain't right.

)O(

decided to stay in the old world.

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
)O(

Point by point arguments is different than just making blanket accusations.

Can you provide any direct citations from the book?

just google 'john holdren ecoscience eugenics quotes', or read the entire book for yourself here http://www.questia.com/PM.qst?a=o&d=98156598

no one denies what I am saying, they just attack me. Do I need to do their research for them? Anyone can look up this book, the entire thing can be read on the internet, there quote are there, he said it, it's in the book. It seems like a lot of people are in denial.

{No, they don't believe you. You need to prove it. So far, you haven't. Now, prove your assertions, or move on. Thank You. SiteMonitor}

)O(

No, but you're the one making the accusations, so the burden of proof is on you.

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]

Do you even read what you write.

BTW, you and your freerepublic pals are full of shit:

http://scienceblogs.com/bioephemera/2009/07/d...

Intellectually disingenuous much?

Stop The American Civil Liberties Union.
You do know that they fight to protect you? Don't you?
OK , you've shown your true colors here dear.
ISP ! ( that means ignore stupid people, just so you know}

the moment he was trying to equate the left and the right. It is the new talking point among wingnuts to help them achieve plausible deniability nirvana.

avoiding that ugly cognitive dissonance sequestered in the darkest back corner of their closed minds...

Direct quote from Ecoscience, promoting coercive fertility control by forced implantation of 'sterilizing capsules', get ready: "The development of a long-term sterilizing capsule that could be implanted under the skin and removed when pregnancy is desired opens additional possibilities for coercive fertility control. The capsule could be implanted at puberty and might be removable, with official permission, for a limited number of births."

That book was written in 1977. Have you ever seen or heard of that kinda thing happening......... in the Last 32 Years?
ohh man, oyyy.

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]

... in the same sense that making up things like the existence of such thing as a "science czar" makes a difference.

... in the same sense that blatantly lying about having read a book, which is almost impossible to find, also makes a difference.

... in the same sense that claiming that fascist parties were somehow leftist, also makes a heck of a lot of difference.

Alas, you seem to be of the opinion, that repeating a falsehood over and over again, it makes it somehow true. Guess who used that as their MO, and guess why makes your silly accusations even the more laughable in the face of your massive projection.

)O(

Actually the boosh administration came close to creating if not a science czar something like an office of such.

They regularly censored global warming reports from national meteorlogy groups as well as NASA, and other federal agencies.

They prevented (like ray gunn) even the mere discussion of birth control in international aid groups.

And they had the Armageddon plan for running the government after a cataclysmic attack on America, and when I was in the Air Force there was scuttlebutt, that America had plans to explode nuclear missles in their silos if there was any chance of Soviet take-over, in an extreme form of scorched earth scenario.

The bad part, I know this part was true, the military was authorized to kill those of us in Communications in case we're on a base that's overrun, to keep us from being captured, particularly those of us with Top Secret Clearances like myself. It was something called a Cypher Clearance.

Just because Holden DISCUSSED eugenics does not mean he thought they were a good idea:

"In 1977, Paul R. Ehrlich, Anne H. Ehrlich, and Holdren co-authored the textbook Ecoscience: Population, Resources, Environment; they discussed the possible role of a wide variety of solutions to overpopulation, from voluntary family planning to enforced population controls, and recommended "the use of milder methods of influencing family size preferences" such as access to birth control and abortion."

Ooops!
Look wut I dun!
I like, wow, actually posted something that supports my claim!
Who knew it could work!?!?!?!1!

I'm sure you still don't understand that excerpted paragraph, as much as I'm sure this link will confuse you:
http://www.scienceprogress.org/2009/07/hold-o...
but hey, maybe like your mushbrained leaders, you too can randomly excerpt passages and twist them into the exact opposite of what they are really saying.

Oh noes! I didn't take things out of context!?!?!

The funny thing is by opposing the public option they are imposing "population controls".. If everyone had quality govt provided un-deniable healthcare then the lifespan of ALL Americans would increase. But without said option a "certain group" of people will have exteneded life spans but the "less desireables" lifespans will actually decrease. So to sum it up those who are against the public option are FOR "population controls"

Enough said about this douche bag.

Another doughy-pantload 2nd generation welfare queen who doesn't have a clue WTF he's talking about. He's so god damned stupid, he doesn't even know the definitions of the words he uses.

The republican party IS corporate fascism. You cannot be both fascist and socialist. They are mutually exclusive terms.

Buy a dictionary you stupid mother f#@$!&^#@%! idiot!

I wonder if 50 years from now, they will play F**ks noise and all these wingnut morons in movies and historical documentaries, just to highlight how totally f**ked-up the MSM once was in America?

"The republican party IS corporate fascism. You cannot be both fascist and socialist. They are mutually exclusive terms." Absolutely . The right can throw the words around like they do because their followers and supporters are too friggin stupid to know the difference . The dumb asses don't even know the definition of a socialist or a fascist . Unbelieveable . It's tough to beat collective stupidy and in such massive numbers . Too damned stupid to reason with .

of the mental institutions. Anyone who does not think this asshole should be in involuntary care needs mental observation and treatment.

Well, Goldberg should have plenty of access to resources for the rich. But he really does need anti depressant meds. Psychotropics will help his self image, you know the sorta half shaved Palestinian look that is so creepy. Who did he pick as his style leader Yassir Arafat?

OOOHHHH...the bitchy blonde is a lawyer.

This is the hard evidence to oppose Health care reform?

If they do not think that Vetrans missing limbs returning are not depessive/suicidal and need that concil. They never sserved this country in battle with the military.

Oh, thats right, Jonah was doing the Cheney thing (more important things than serving) and Meygan spent her time putting on make up while our troops protected them.

Where was Jonah during Bush's term when the Walter Reed story broke? How did Bush treat them returning veterans?

Did Megan and Jonah discuss the story of the Bush Adm, via Rumsfeld having American's dead return to be cremated in a dog crematory?

All I can tell you is that the Heritage Foundation groomed Jonah to become the voice of the right that writes the story that America could have prevented the Civil War by the north simply buying slaves from the south. Not that the south would replenish the slave market? Jonah lusts to be the next David Frum.

These right wingers are completely out of control. It's sick, sad, and totally disgusting. Nothing is off limits. No lie is too great. No boundary of decency they will not cross. They've now gone from frightening the elderly to frightening veterans. I really fear for this country with so many right wing lunatics out there trying to start an anarchist stampede. What's so frightening is they they command their own news television network and dominate radio. I fear their lunacy may be contagious, since it appears that Americans are quite a cowardly bunch given how easily they respond to fear mongering.

that we Americans are cowardly. Maybe it's worth noting that the majority of us have been raised to perceive television news as rock solid and unbiased. Maybe it's worth noting that the majority of us have become increasingly enamoured of the flashy, loud, mesmerizing computer graphics that provide the framework for the 'news' we are getting. Maybe it's worth noting that the propagandists have done decades of research on how to present their message so that most of us perceive it as truth.

I am a fix-it kinda gal, and an optimist. As an activist, I tend toward pacifism in its purest form. I seek opportunities to talk with conservatives and others on the right, and I have noted a big increase in the number of people whose minds are closed to seeking solutions, whose world views are both pessimistic and fear-driven, and who think that carrying a gun to a town hall meeting is a fundamental right. Almost all of my attempts to dialogue with such individuals are frustrating and fruitless.

Since Bush sacrificed most of our National Guard to the illegal invasion of Iraq and the ongoing quagmire in Afghanistan, we will be pressed to defend ourselves when these zealots begin their revolt. I fear it's only a matter of time...

)O(

I tried to open that link last night, and not only did it take forever to load, but when you clicked on particular arguments on the left, they would only open chapter summaries or perhaps abstracts, but not actual text.

I'm sorry Jonah. Trying to score political points with a vial NAZI comparison. You've no longer have right to bear the name. I hereby rename you shithead.

Goldberg

)O(

I read the rantings of this idiot in the Los Angeles Times. Since FOX got into the game, seems like every major network or paper in this country has to "balance" their normal reporting with comments from Crazyland. Sort of a Walter Winchell meets Forest Gump aspect.

SOYLENT GREEN IS PEOPLE! SOYLENT GREEN IS PEOPLE!

Noted and added to the loser file.

Screaming "Nazi" or "Socialist" seems to be all the GOP rage today - but remember a little project in Cold Spring Harbour (Long Island, US of A) in 1904 funded by those GREAT AMERICANS RETHUGLICANS the Rockefellers, Harrimans, Bushies and Carnegies? Wait for it........yup, EUGENICS! Early 1900's saw 27 states enacting laws that provided for prevention of marriage, residency and involuntary sterilizations; over 60K documented sterilizations were performed, most in sunny California. Great minds, all Rethuglicans of the day, backed by the leading "scholars" from Princeton, Stamford, Harvard and Yale wereon board. Read "Blood of a Nation" from Stamford President David Jordon. Were did Adolf get ideas, funding and support - ?

142 comments

Login or Register to post comments.