Rachel Maddow: The Republicans' Small Angry Tent
By Heather Saturday Sep 12, 2009 4:30pm
Rachel Maddow weighs in on the fringe elements of the conservative movement taking over the Republican party and she hits the nail on the head with this statement:
MADDOW: It doesn‘t make sense anymore to talk about the relationship between the extreme fringe of the conservative movement and the modern Republican Party, because you can only discern a relationship between two things if you can tell those two things apart.
She followed up with Lincoln Chafee who believes this is going to assure they continue to lose elections since there is no room left in the Republican party for moderates.
Transcript below the fold.
MADDOW: But we begin tonight with what could fairly be judged as a distraction from the president‘s health care message last night, but it is a distraction that‘s also turning out to be a very clarifying look at American politics. The South Carolina Republican Congressman Joe Wilson, who yelled “You lie” at the president in the middle of his address to Congress last night, today felt himself on the receiving end of support and congratulations for that outburst.
While many of his Republican colleagues in Congress express their disapproval of what Congressman Wilson did, a steady stream of well-wishers descended upon the congressman‘s office in D.C. today to say quite the opposite. Among them were radical anti-abortion activist Randall Terry and members of the Montgomery, Alabama Tea Party Patriots. Congressman Wilson also found a wealth of support from conservative outposts on the online machines.
Today, the conservative Web site Palmetto Scoop began giving away “I‘m with Joe Wilson” t-shirts. The RedState blog dubbed Congressman Wilson, quote, “A great American hero,” urging its readers to “open our wallets for Joe.”
For his part, Congressman Wilson released a YouTube video tonight incredibly trying to raise money off his newfound notoriety saying, “I will not be muzzled,” and railing against, quote, “the liberal who is want to give health care to illegals.”
The groups that have come to Congressman Wilson‘s defense over the past 24 hours, that have even literally come to his office to show their support can help us understand the state of American politics right now, at least the state of Republican politics right now—the extent to which the Republican Party has integrated itself with its own fringe extremes.
Joe Wilson is not a well-known congressnan. And he‘s not a well-known congressman for a reason. He‘s not considered to be an extremist in his party. He‘s considered to be a typical back-bench Republican congressman.
And right now, in American politics today, being a typical back-bench Republican member of Congress means doing things like opening the doors of your congressional office to participants in the 9/12 March on Washington, which Congressman Joe Wilson is planning to do this Saturday. The 9/12 March on Washington is essentially a national tea party, a big organized ostensibly grassroots march on the nation‘s capital.
If you go to their Web site, you‘ll see that, quote, “We‘ve had enough of the out-of-control spending. We are gathering on 9/12/2009 to deliver our message in person that we‘ve had enough.” The “we” here is actually the Republican-run corporate-funded organization called FreedomWorks. FreedomWorks is charging some groups tens of thousands of dollars to take part in these grassroots events.
Today, during the kickoff event for this whole weekend of 9/12 things, the head of FreedomWorks, former Republican House Majority Leader Dick Armey, came to Congressman Joe Wilson‘s defense, arguing that we should, quote, “cut Mr. Wilson a little slack.”
The crowd of several hundred people who were listening to Mr. Armey at that rally reportedly shouted “You lie, you lie!”—not because they thought Dick Armey was lying but because they liked that Congressman Joe Wilson yelled that last night at the president in the middle of his address to Congress.
If you look at 9/12 march Web site, you can see the organizations who are sponsoring the event. One group that‘s listed as a bronze co-sponsor of the event is called the National Association of Rural Landowners, or NARLO.
If you surf on over to the NARLO Web site, it turns out that they‘re calling for violent revolution. They‘re calling for the overthrow of the United States government. The government and the media both described as, quote, “our enemy within.” “Unless we come together in a cohesive, fighting unit, our freedoms and liberties shall fade into the dark chasm of socialism and radical environmentalism.”
Included on the Web site of this group that, again, is a bronze sponsor of the 9/12 march on Saturday, is an ominous warning that, quote, “a day of reckoning is at hand.” They also encourage people who are visitors to their Web site to buy guns now. They also posted a video that forecasts massive protests followed by the rapid secession of states, followed by a new civil war.
Congressman Joe “You lie!” Wilson is opening his congressional office to these nice folks for the 9/12 march. The march will also be addressed by Republican members of Congress, including Tom Price and Mike Pence and Marsha Blackburn. Also, Republican Senator Jim DeMint will be speaking.
It doesn‘t make sense anymore to talk about the relationship between the extreme fringe of the conservative movement and the modern Republican Party, because you can only discern a relationship between two things if you can tell those two things apart.
About half an hour ago, the top-ranking Republican in the House of Representatives—not some anonymous back-bencher nobody‘s ever heard of until he had a tantrum on television—the top-ranking Republican in the House of Representatives, the minority leader, John Boehner, appeared on a webcast organized by the lobbying arm of the Family Research Council.
This is an anti-health care reform webcast. It features the top Republican in the House of Representatives and it is hosted by a group that describes health reform as, quote, “Obama‘s tax-and-death power grab” which will, quote, “produce a moral disaster and enable the Washington liberals to use your taxes to turn their entire anti-life agenda—from unrestricted abortion on demand to euthanasia—into national health care policy.”
Getting called a liar was a distraction from President Obama‘s speech on health care last night. It created a circus-like spectacle last night and, frankly, all day today. And, it was also a clarifying moment about who the opposition is right now, for the president and for Democrats—and maybe for some moderate Republicans.






Login or Register to post comments.
Moderate Republicans? Blue Dog Democrats.
If Obama would get some ba..s and kick Emanuel out of being his republican advisor , then maybe Obama would get some fight in him..
How can we expect anything from the elected democrats when we have republicans elected on our democrat ticket like the blue dogs and some of the centrists like Emanuel , Feinstein and other..
No, sorry. Deranged right-wing lunatic fascists? Mainstream Republicans.
Conservative Republicans? Blue-Dog Democrats.
Moderate Republicans? DEMOCRATS.
Liberals? Not in any elected position in this country except for Bernie Sanders.
We keep hearing about how decimated the Republican party is, then we see polls that show Republican's winning an awful lot of races.
How do you explain that?
Polls reflect the population being polled. Who's represented in those polls?
As we have seem in the past 2000 & 2004,,, Polls are setup for thief of close races for the republicans.
Wonder how many other races we do not know of...
Do you really believe that Obama would have won a close race??
What?
The tent is plenty full of people of little intelligence and intelligent people lacking in empathy.
What elections? There haven't been any except local and that is meaningless.
These are the thoughts that came to my mind when I saw the report on CNN.
Incest
Racist
Incest
Racist
Incest
Racist
I even think that some of them could have even been related to themselves.
Some of them go back in time and come out their own dicks.
If not their own asses.
They are human related somehow. . .
I'm thinking some have to come from under a rock or a bridge?
A sad commentary about the state and nature of humans in general.
How or why does the GOP even exist? To show how unbalanced they can be?
I just do not get it.
I know it's been mentioned before but honest2gawd the simularities between the current U.S. political landscape and this movie are downright spooky:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=upvZdVK913I
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ke5Mr5eCF2U&fe...
Lou Dobbs' granddady, sayin' what needs to be said!
There is a moral to the story:
That all Governments lie, including our own, when it suits their purposes.
The key is to lie first. The most important rule in propaganda is to get the first word out on a given subject. Ninety percent of the time the person who takes the initiative wins the battle.
To force the other party, the truth tellers, to answer your lies, to defend the indefensible, to explain whether they still beat their dog or did they recently stop beating their dog. Are you a communist/fascist/despot or did you change to recently to a communist/socialist/fascist/despot?
Lie early, repeat it often, challenge the authority of those who argue against you, use ad hominem attacks regularly, use straw-men arguments, and change the subject if the discussion drifts toward solution.
Unfortunately the mass media in this country is owned and operated by rich white guys. Guess who's story they are going to get out.
Do you mean WORMs?
As in White Old Rich Men.
For example, it should have been "MEDICARE FOR ALL," not "SINGLE PAYER" or "PUBLIC OPTION." The other side sees the word "public," and think "communism."
Medicare is something most people will eventually need. Anytime the other side would say anything negative about it, all one would have to do is say, "Then of course you'll state now unequivocally that you will promise NEVER to access your Medicare, right?"
And there should have been more of a emphasis on stopping waste in Medicare, to stave off the other side pushing that issue.
South Carolina has become the new racist Alabama and Mississippi. At least it's a something to reach for. I've got an idea. Let's redraw the American borders. Start with Texas and include Alabama, Mississippi, Florida, Georgia Tennessee, Oklahoma, parts of Arkansas, and South Carolina. They're the states that draw the most federal funds anyway and bitch the most. Let them leave. The countries education rate will increase dramatically and we'll save a boat load of money. Tell you what, they can have Ohio too. It may cost us a little more when it comes to border control a bit but who needs them. We need to keep the Dakotas, Idaho and Wyoming for hunting vacation spots. I'm not quite sure what to do with Louisiana. IF I want a good party I need New Orleans.
gump South Carolina already has a Christian Heritage (read white) movement that intends on secession with the longer larger goal to convert all the states to Christian states etc etc.
SC was always conservative. Had folks up in the northern part of Pickens County that would say they still weren't part of the union, BJU is upstate. But after that movement, it feels different now somehow.
Look at the districts that have had those guys moving in, then look at the districts swinging hard right. DeMint is from upstate before Senator, Gresham Barrett is from up there, Inglis may not be right enough anymore.
When I see these angry, ignorant people I think of the "Battle Hymn of the Republic", and the part about the " grapes of wrath." The Vintage is getting big and tiresome.
"Stupid is forever, ignorance can be fixed."
Don Wood
And:
"Nothing is worse than active ignorance."
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749 - 1832)
http://www.franciscodegoya.net/114437/El-Suen...
I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
Your cousins to the north watch in awe as you seemingly self-destruct over this.
My health-care in Canada is fabulous...and it's free.
It's also a no-brainer.
Is the combined IQ of the American population that low or is it just a few that are stickin' it to the rest?
"Is the combined IQ of the American population that low or is it just a few that are stickin' it to the rest?"
Some of both, I imagine.
The 'few' being Fox News and the right-wing crazies (ie, Dick Armey) out there spreading lies and misinformation.
Seeing the size of the crowd at the DC protest today, their strategy seems to be working.
I saw a CNN clip today of a woman saying, "Muslims are taking over America."
Sad.
The size of the crowd does not represent the volume that the media wants you to believe. The lunatic morons have always been out there. But now, with a President that looks a "bit" different, they get lots of air time because they're acting so stupid and repeating any idiotic talking point that their favorite on-air personality throws out. And with their elected officials joining the madness, the GOP is becoming more and more unhinged by the day. Don't worry, enough sane people have taken notice.
even at my age, I would move to Canada in a heartbeat if I had the money......it is down right depressing with all that is going on in this country........and it obviously isn't difficult to dispense lies and misinformation to a bunch of loonies who probably can't even spell most of the words they try to use........I'm soooooooo tired of it all.................:(
Think about how stupid the average person is, and then realize that half of the people are dumber than that!
-George Carlin
That would explain the 46% of voters that McStupid and Carrie's mom got.
now, no more so than Canada. I've NEVER voted Republican, ever, even sheriff, judge, whatever. As I would not lump all Canadians together please do not do so with us.
It just seems that you have more loons per capita than average.
Maybe it's the water in the south.
And who, Rachel, would they be?
Realistically, there is no longer any such thing as a moderate Republican. When a Republican representative or senator casts a vote in support of the GOP leadership, they are, by definition, admitting that they are NOT moderate. Moderates don't support lunatics.
The Blue Dog Democrats, of course.
I usta like wearing my hair long with just a little hint of fringe.
The SCLM will not report on the true nature of the fringers and the Bush supreme court is about to unleash the power of corporations on our elections.
The five most dangerous, and un-american SOB's whoever lived!
Apart from them inciting run of the mill criminal acts like murder, many of us are wondering how far things will go before their "freedom of speech" become acts of sedition?
They're like little kids that have to be reminded where the boundaries are.
Or translated into teabag speak for the thicker skulls:
"Line, you is over it."
with a fellow Liberal and we agreed to disagree on why the right-wingers are reacting the way they are today. He said that it was only because a Democrat was elected to the W.H. and that the Democrats controlled the Congress. I pointed out to him that it is because a Black Democrat was elected to the W.H. Because of Obama being black is why one sees all the hate from the right-wing. If a white man had been elected, one would have seen some disruption, but not to the extreme we have today.
Racism is rampant in the right-wing and it's on display every day, even in Congress. Downright disgusting.
After reviewing much of the video covering the DC anti-Obama protesters, I have to ask....do many of these people handle our food? Are they allowed to handle heavy equipment or operate lathes? How much actual interface do we have with these people? I getting anxious.
Theres clever choosing of photograph and words to accompany it on their front page.
http://imgur.com/3X4cf.png
"Assails his critics"
Look at the parallels between the historical rise of fascist movements in other countries and the recent trajectory of the Republicans in this one: the "big tent" of old-line establishment conservatives discredit themselves and are thus marginalized; the hardcore fringe element they have always courted yet never before taken seriously is all that is left of their "base;" they panic and cynically turn to the hard-line base fringe as the new core of their party, catering to their lunatic beliefs and ultimately surrendering themselves to the unbending fringe ideology and thuggery to which they must now subscribe in order to remain relevant. Hence what's left of mainstream Repubs cynically spouting the Birther/Deather horseshit, etc. Historically, movements like this either flame out or take over. Which will it be here?
Login or Register to post comments.