Pat Buchanan Calls Sotomayor a "Lightweight" and "Anti-White" Judge
By Heather Tuesday Jun 02, 2009 4:30am
Pat Buchanan on Washington Journal continues his trashing of Sonia Sotomayor as an affirmative action, lightweight, anti-white judge. He repeats the better portion of his May 29th op-ed Obama's Idea of Justice with a few additional insults thrown in for good measure.
Media Matters has an article with his op-ed posted and links to some of his talking points that they've already debunked.
During this interview Buchanan went even further than the op-ed and said this when asked about calling her a "lightweight":
Buchanan: Well I, again in that Saturday piece, she went to Princeton. She graduated first in her class it said. But she herself said she read, basically classic children's books to read and learn the language and she read basic English grammars and she got help from tutors. I think that, I mean if you're, frankly if you're in college and you're working on Pinocchio or on the troll under the bridge, I don't think that's college work.
Here's the portion of the New York Times article Buchanan was referencing.
Judge Sotomayor is not known to have identified herself as a beneficiary of affirmative action, but she has described her academic struggles as a new student at Princeton from a Roman Catholic school in the Bronx — one of about 20 Hispanics on a campus with more than 2,000 students.
She spent summers reading children’s classics she had missed in a Spanish-speaking home and “re-teaching” herself to write “proper English” by reading elementary grammar books. Only with the outside help of a professor who served as her mentor did she catch up academically, ultimately graduating at the top of her class.
I've heard a lot of ignorant B.S. from Buchanan over the last week or so, but this one takes the cake. He questions whether she actually even graduated at the top of her class or at best deserved to when you see him qualifying the reporting on her class rank with "it said". Then he tries to equate someone doing what they needed to in order to make up for a less than stellar education growing up and equates that with her "college work". Never mind "it said" that she did eventually make her way to the head of the class and overcome that hurdle.
You're a real piece of work Buchanan. I expect we'll be treated to more of this on Morning Joe or one of Pat's other countless appearances on MSNBC for the week.
Buchanan goes on to compare Sotomayor's intellectual rigor to that of, among others, .... Clarence Thomas.
Buchanan: But I will say this. She's going to have an opportunity up before that hearing to demonstrate she's a Scalia, or an Alito, or a John Roberts, or a Clarence Thomas in terms of understanding the law.
Yeah, Clarance Thomas. The guy who doesn't even want to stay awake during court. He then says that her "whole career is about affirmative action". Where the hell is Lawrence O'Donnell when you need him? C-SPAN treated everyone to an hour of this garbage this morning.
Think Progress and their wonderful think tank over there took Buchanan to task for me as well. Thank you Amanda for and the rest of the crew there for the great work you're doing and for some additional analysis on Buchanan's remarks.






Login or Register to post comments.
Buchanan speaks as all of the GOP elite today do of the college educated; with scorn and cries of derision and "otherness". "they're not like us", they say, "they're dirty liberal intellectuals". has Buchanan himself ever been in a college classroom i wonder? anyone who's had a liberal arts education knows full well from experience that some classes come easy while others in a different area of academia come harder and require more work and sometimes creative methods to absorb. sotomayor's reading elementary english texts is such a creative method. Buchanan is a fool not to recognize this fact. either that or he's merely a liar for refusing to acknowledge it.
I'm going with LIAR!
things in our culture that reference back to these books. I think she was smart to read them and claim what she either felt she missed or truly did miss. She passed her F'n classes at Princenton so who cares what she did with her free time. These people focus on the most trivial of details.
i go with bucketbrainshit is a RACIST
and is definitely intimidated by SMART anyone.
he is showing his true
lack ofcoloras a flaccid old wanker.
i suspect buchanan is suffering clitoris envy. that
tired face of his is beginning to look rather like
dingy drapes.
Yawn.
Look at who his married to. That tells you how his two brain cells work.
long-time affirmative action recipients like buchanan and george will always crack me up, thinking they somehow are the standard-bearers of erudition, learning and meritocracy! bwahahahahah...
if you ask me it takes more intelligence and creative thought to use classic children's stories to brush up on one's english grammer, than to memorize and regurgitate right-wing myths and talking points as uncle pat has been doing his whole career.
you might try a little remedial eduation yourself there, pat!
I bought a copy of "Go Dog Go," in Spanish to help me with my Spanish. Much easier to master language when you're learning or perfecting it via a children's book, rather than trying to pick up "War and Peace" and learn the language through that.
Pat is Native american isn't he? If so he has a right to opinionate about immigration. But what makes him an expert on judges again?
He's Irish - and a classic bully from the get-go. I believe there's a book about him somewhere - he may even have written it.
*
some of his ancestors were - but he was born and bred in Washington, DC. He has a degree from Columbia University - same
school as Obama, and he's worked for Nixon, Ford and Reagan. So, that gives you an idea about how f**ked up he is.
I think he's really stopped taking his meds for his dementia.
Big difference...not. Those of us with ancestry in the
British Isles are all mixed up.
When we weren't killing each other, hochmagandy was the norm.
Don't let the white racist hear you. If he finds out that people think he looks like a man of color it will shatter his black little heart!
The GOP has basically shrunken to the point where it is now only a xenophobic party of racist white men. Little surprise, then, that they should make these sorts of claims, no matter how scurrilous. It's all they've got.
You really don't give them enough credit. And how about the tender feelings of Coultergeist, Ingraham and Barbara Bush? This description is more accurate :
Re=Thugs -- the party of immature, voraciously rapacious, depraved, despotic, doughy white, cowardly, angry troglodytes, bigots, racists, perverts, xenophobes, pedophiles, murderers, war criminals, homophobes, misogynists, self-righteous hypocrites, self-hating women, fetid wombs, preeminent whiners and consummate chronic liars.
*
You gonna list their bad points now?
You saw more moderate Republicans on tv last nite then you had in years.
Again, the two parties poll every day. The polls for the GOP are getting scarey, and party leaders are in full blown panic.
They are unable to rein in the extreme wing of the party, and that wing is in the process of destroying any chance of the GOP being a viable national party.
when you create the monster and lie down with dogs to do it you end up with a monster with fleas I guess. They sold their souls to get to this point and they deserve every last bit of angst that they are experiencing.
they got the conservatives of the religious right to run for school boards, then city councils, then state and national offices on their ticket. They now own the party, body and soul. They all deserve one another, but I totally agree with Liberal AND PROUD. They've got a tiger by the tail and don't know what to do. Couldn't happen to a more deserving bunch.
Or has the assassination of DR. Tiller by the xtian terrorist have the rightwing punditry a bit worried?
Worried that all the hate speech they've been spewing forth is beginning to bear fruit, and not only will it be massively counterproductive to their cause, but also, that they could be considered somewhat responsible...
See my comment above. The GOP is starting to look like an impending plane crash...flames coming out of the windows and nose down in a death spiral.
I dunno...too sophisticated for the GOP...
I'm thinkin it's more like an old steam locomotive goin off the overpass in a heap of obsolete technology and hissing hot air.
A frigate (circa 1700s)... once the pride and power of the ocean is sinking... many have abandoned ship... leaving the rats to try to spoon out the water.
Has Rush weighed in (no pun intended) on the Dr. Tiller matter yet? I don't think he even mentioned it yesterday?
Laura Ingraham had either a guest or caller on yesterday to discuss this situation. They ranted on and on about how abortion was wrong for several minutes. At the very end she made some weak statement about killing the doctor being wrong then turned around and said it was no more wrong than all the babies that have been murdered. She actually discussed this as if women were just making a decision late in a pregnancy to abort simply because they didn't want a baby. Unbelievable!
she can always fly to Europe on vacation if she "has a little problem".
...even neo-Nazi Pat Buchanan can appear on C-SPAN and speak what passes for his mind.
Thank god for Pat Buchanan. He is (goose)stepping where others fear to tread.
The tragic and under-reported plight of the Oppressed and Misunderstood Doughy White Male Misogynistic Bigot.
Does society have a more desperately repressed minority?
*
intelligence.
Pat seems to be so arrogant as to think that because Ms. Sotomayor grew up in a home that spoke Spanish she's automatically got an inferior IQ or something.
Just because Sotomayor had to brush up on her English skills while in college, that does not mean that she doesn't have the intellectual rigor for the Supreme Court. In fact, she had the chops to succeed in college while she improved her English, and clearly she has a great command of the language now.
When I was in my high school German classes, I had a friend there who'd immigrated here from Iceland. She told me that she was very annoyed when she first enrolled at the high school because the counselors kept wanting to place her in remedial classes (Math, History, etc.)
In actuality, she's a brilliant girl and she arrived in the States already speaking Icelandic, Danish, and English.
If speaking English as an oh so superior first language guaranteed high intelligence, we wouldn't be saddled with Dubya, would we?
I haven't noticed Dubya speaking English.
.
"If speaking English as an oh so superior first language guaranteed high intelligence, we wouldn't be saddled with Dubya, would we?"
wait, dubya speaks coherent english? when did that happen?
boosh's into glossolalia:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeguOPBE-vs&fe...
Uncle Pat is sort of like the drunk uncle who shows up on the doorstep one morning and then never goes away. Is anybody really listening to the old fart?
Holy shit, you mean to tell me that she took it upon herself to improve her reading and writing? What was she thinking? She actually aspired to something? The very nerve of her! Didn't she understand that according to Pat's way of thinking, she could never be equal to old pasty white men with narrow minds and terrible comb overs?
/snark/
What Trittydi said.
To Repukes anyone who disagrees with them is anti-white; hell everyone else in America is anti-white to them.
Just one more nail in the coffin (or stake through the heart) of the Repuke party because America is becoming more and more "of color" every year (mostly Latino) and here they are alienated them all. Way to go Pukes, keep up the good work, mofos.
In what way is this not an inspirational story? Do the terms 'American dream' and 'pulling yourself up by your bootstraps' mean nothing to these people.
I thought that was what the republicans are all about, leaving people to do for themselves like pulling themselves up by their bootstraps. Isn't that their mantra, don't depend on govt to help you?
Ivy League grads like Buchannan and O'Reilly like to denounce college as bastions of liberalism, so that's the angle they imply with Sotomayor.
So how does a C average legacy student get regarded as one of the greatest presidents to this ilk?
I hope this sorry bigot lives another thirty years and suffers as he witnesses the change to complete representative diversity in this Nation.
"I think that, I mean if you're, frankly if you're in college and you're working on Pinocchio or on the troll under the bridge, I don't think that's college work."
I bet after he said that he did his big ha ha ha laugh. He always laughs when he thinks he has made a smart snide remark....even if no one laughs with him.
I didn't start college until I was 26.
When I tested they said my math skills were border-line between remedial and college level. So I signed up for remedial and wore out my tutors.
I can calculate in my head generally to fractions including adding and subtracting and decimals, and with a pencil quadratic equations (although I need to refresh myself on some of the final points.) I always had difficulties with word problems and order-of-operations.)
Two trolls from Transylvannia leave their castle for the bridge at 1100 hours. Troll A. goes by Pinnochio's house which adds 2km. to his journey. Both walk at the same pace, 15km. per hour. The direct distance to the bridge from the castle is 40 km. Because Troll B is a lightweight, maintaining the same pace
with Troll A actually gives him a 5% speed advantage. Obviously
Troll B will reach the bridge first, but how much time does Count Dracula have to suck B dry before A arrives?
how much time does Count Dracula have to suck B dry before A arrives?
There's a comment crying out to be deleted!!
my Extra Credit question for our resident math scholar.
I am hoping it doesn't happen before he gets the appropriate silent Vlad footage posted.
18 minutes? (roughly)
If I'm way off, it's probably why I'm a journalist and not a mathematician.
Can't decide if Pat is more upset because Sotomayor is a woman, or because she's "non-white."
Molly Ivins had Pat's number years ago. His rants always "sound better in the original German."
I swear, Pat's soul could fit inside a gnat's ear.
If he implies the her reading academic were light because she was reading children book for her English comprehension, then he assumes that her native language are nothing, when in fact we have had Hispanic writer win the Pulitzer prize for best literature.
It seems to imply that any college in the world that doesn't teach in English may be suspect too. Buchanan is just another warped nativist radical who has NO business being on our television screens.
into a demented mind.
How does this bigot Buchanan stay on the air?
Is he a sounding board for rich white guys who feel threatened?
Please, Mr. Buchanan could you read me a bedtime story? How about Pinocchio or the concern troll under the bridge?
Keep them coming you Conservative redneck-in-ties Mofos and watch your poll numbers drop!
...Even when somebody takes the initiative and improves her English speaking skills, it's still a problem for you isn't? Once a sp*c always a sp*c, right Pat? Why is this piece of shit on my teevee? Why is he writing op-ed columns? Pat Buchanan is just another redneck; David Duke without the Dixie drawl.
and the charm.
a self-made American, someone who overcame the poverty and immigrant status of her birth and youth to become a brilliant, mainstream success. She's what Repugs claim they idolize--someone who did it without welfare, handouts, or affirmative action (after all, why should we help those less fortunate than ourselves?), using only her wits and enormous hard work to become nominated to the nation's highest court. Really, they should be using her example to shame the rest of the lazy, stupid brown people out there.
But here they are, despising her and tearing her down. Why? Because she's not white or male. Turns out that only men or white women (maybe Asian women, too--I can't fathom the way they think) are subject to being "real American" (read Republican) success stories. It says so much about how small the souls of these men really are.
She's not an immigrant, she's Puerto Rican. Aside from that, your comment is spot on.
As a person that has to read children's stories on a daily basis, they are fantastically simple yet complex. My kid has a treasure trove of stories including Shakespeare for children. He's 6.
According to this sick old man, only minorities can be racist.
The article doesn't say she read children's classics to learn English. She could have read them to fill a cultural gap so she would understand things like "the troll under the bridge". And she wasn't necessarily 'learning' English with her mentor, she could have been upgrading to "proper English". Proper, academic level English is much more rigorous than everyday or even high school English. Having just finished one year on an MFA after finishing undergraduate work 30 years ago, I can understand wanting a tutor to take your writing from very good to excellent.
But poor old Pat wouldn't understand an of this.
jeez, what crawled into Pats bonnet?
And then bored into his skull.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JehjqlzXwIQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVZUVeMtYXc
She should be a huge inspiration to a lot of kids, especially little girls who were not born with that lovely silver spoon. I imagine she and the President have given a whole lot of kids hope where maybe they saw none before. We should be proud to be a country that can do that and just ignore Buchanan and his ilk.
fun semi related piece.
http://www.counterpunch.org/cockburn05292009....
Why is the big white man so afraid of the intelligent woman?
Hey you smart women, get off my lawn!
Wasn't he a speechwriter for the third worst prez of the USA?
I always thought Nixon was the worst, but Dumbya/Darth take the crown!
Reagan turns out to be #2 on the list for laying the foundation for the ruin of the US economy.
I couldn't listen to the whiny auld shite,"My porridge is lumpy, LUMPY I tell you!"
Buchanan is a unique specimen and deserves special protection. I hope he donates his brain to science so that, one day, mankind can develop a vaccine.
Yeh! She's a 'lightweight' because she's not full of shit, like her Reich-wing detractors. Keep it up boys, you, and your 'party' are history, and hystrionics won't change that.
Tue, 06/02/2009 - 06:26 — goldfish swirling
Buchanan is a unique specimen and deserves special protection. I hope he donates his brain to science so that, one day, mankind can develop a vaccine.
_______________________________________________________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOe_4mgmyyA&fe...
Times have changed and it's time he got out of politics.
She obviously weighs less than Pat, and being a sane persons she's anti-Buchanan -> Buchanan is white, thus she is anti white. Gotta give it to Pat, that's bout as close to rational thinking as Pat gets.
Why would anyone give a raving rats ass what Pat Buchanan thinks. He is there for entertainment purposes only.
I wouldn't call an over-the-hill white bigot spewing hatred and stupidity entertainment!! That would be like having a front row seat at Gitmo.............oh, wait......
Buchanan is threatened by the fact she is a woman, ethnicity has little to do with it other than he can point to a few comments and say the majority of folks in this country will be on the losing end of her rulings. The truth of the matter is he is totally threatened by women in influential positions greater than his own. Weak Pat, you're a tiny weak little man.
Buchanan on Condi Rice:
"Finally, Condi Rice is not a conservative— she's a neoconservative. And the neoconservatives have won virtually every battle now. They have all the seats of power. And they are not loved in this D.C., not simply by the bureaucracy, but by some traditionalist old Right folks(project much?), by a lot of journalists and others. And what the president has got — he's basically declared war on this city with a very narrow set of alliances".
He is soooooooo intimidated by women of any color.
he's never been able to get his hands on one.
....to summon the nice men in the white uniforms. Buchannan needs a straight jacket, a padded room and a low external stimulus environment.
None of these then?
http://thezeninyou.com/wordpress/wp-content/u...
choppers on the beleaguered Ms. Fawcett.
She's also anti-white? That's oxymoronic? Huh?
He asks if she is like Alito, Scalia, Roberts and Thomas in terms of understanding the law, or if she is like Ginsburg. I want to find out too, because if she is anything like Alito, Scalia, Roberts and Thomas, she should absolutely be rejected. I still can't understand how these fools ever got to the bench in the first place.
of them. That's how.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TG4f9zR5yzY
Too true.
Keep talkin', Pat. We're all waiting to see if you can go just a little bit further out onto that ledge. Keep going...
Buchanan has a macaca moment in ..5...4...3...
was the half Jewish/half Korean guy Buchanan has writing for him.
RIGHT WING THINKING: When you find yourself hopelessly trapped deep in a hole of your own digging, the best solution is to call for reenforcements to bring you more shovels!
they can't even see that they're in a hole.
Buchanan and his breed are dying out fast and they can't handle the reality that they're losing their power. When you're reduced to flailing about and talking sheer nonsense, the end is near.
RIP forever!
Waddya call male Caucasians getting drunk?
Whitey-Tighties.
http://cgi.ebay.com.my/Whitey-Tighty-Tie-Lot-...
when you use the work "whitey!"
No sarcasm, etc.
Two sets of rules even here!
Which is an ironic statement coming from Buchanan, because as it turns out, those are the only books he has ever read front to back in his entire life.
Would it demonstrate her intellect
To have read My Pet Goat
While holding it upside-down?
she can do better than that.
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_Skoh-lE8sO0/Rxj_UfE...
That's Pat!
...a thoroughly dishonest GOP shill. Why is this liar given any airtime at all?
Fuck Patty Buchanann. The left likes to portray him and a crotchety old grandpa but he is nothing less that Rush in grandpa's clothes. He is the Lou Dobbs of MSNBC. What an old punk he is.
I would like to see Buchanann have to go to one of the best Spanish speaking schools in the world and graduate at the top of any class in that institution. What an asshole.
I say this seriously...I think the guy is locked into an 80 IQ. He really isn't that bright...but he has a big yapper. WHY he gets coverage is beyond me. Maybe he's "a nice guy" or something...but Jesus...give it a rest.
They talk about VP Joe Biden sticking his foot in his mouth. This guy has it lodged there.
they wouldn't be so afraid of her. Weakness and fear = the trademarks of the radical right.
That clip was vile.
What amazes me is that the interviewer didn't make a single objection to Buchanan's inflammatory bullshit. He just let the guy vent his lies.
I thought CSPAN was supposed to be better than Fox News.
Lawrence O'Donnell has given numerous textbook examples on exactly how to Mr. America(circa 1904)'s racist ass.
you old bigot, STFU.
MSNBC needs to fire his ass off the network.
Pat calls Sotomayor anti-white and an intellectual light-weight. So, how does he know? Has he read any of her decisions, or is he basing this on her comments, taken out of context? I mean, if you're going to throw these types of fireballs, shouldn't you do SOME research first?
I mean, for example, the New Haven case. She was 1 of a 3 judge panel who affirmed a LOWER COURT'S decision. Were the other 2 judges "anti-white"? How about the judge in the lower court; was he or she a "reverse racist"? How about the New Haven city council? Are they ALL racist?
Oh, BTW, one of the firefighters Sonia ruled against was hispanic. So, is the Latina judge anti-white AND anti-hispanic and pro black?
Cmon, Pat, that doesn't make sense. Go back to defending the 3rd Reich.
for a SCOTUS hearing. It contains a major issue that needs an absolute and final determination. That is most likely why it was put on that track by the appeals panel. That is one of the most important functions of SCOTUS. To settle law.
Old White Man Racist Pig.
... having arrived in the U.S at age 20, I don't know the contents of any of the books that children read. Often - in the adult world - references are made to some parts within some of the better known popular books, TV shows, etc. - something about wicked witches, whales and white picket fences - I am totally clueless to some of the references. Maybe I should read some of those books, but I have other things to do. (Hänsel und Gretel and Tischlein deck dich und Knüppel aus dem Sack I know about). In court hearings where often references are made and analogies used, it would definitely be advantageous to know about those things. She did the smart thing.
Pukeanan has always been a really, really, ignorant Reslug racist and bigot. Intelligent Americans turn off HATE monguering assholes like him.
to label other people with a longer list of achievements as a "light weight."
Where do these people get the gall. Seriously, Buchanan, what the f*ck have you ever done other than being fortunate enough not to be sent to the pen for Watergate?
Right on Pat.
And George Bush was SUCH an intellectual guy known for his command of the english language!
for too long REAL americans have been forced to endure anti-white sentiment or as Rush would say reverse racism (since racism is racism unless of course it is directed at white people). the poor upper class white males of this country have suffered long enough. it's about time people finally started to stand up for the little guys who have been running business and politics for the last thousand years or so. while some would argue that anything that is today, is essentially their fault since they have been in charge of everything for so long, this is simply incorrect. because these great underdogs are christian they may have let their faith interfere with their judgment and made the simple mistake of being too nice to the non-white everyone else in the worlds and allowed them to create this modern time of persecution. If i am not to worry about the pat buchanans, rush limbaughs, or bill o'rielly's of the world then who should i worry about? when these proud men are getting into their luxury cars and take the long arduous drive to their beach houses and their car stereos happen to fall on a radical leftwing extremist hate radio station like npr, for that moment they may have to question their own actions. no one should have to endure that process of reflection. forcing powerful white men to look in the mirror makes water boarding look like a nice day at the pool (which as far as their concerned it is).
so the time is now, if we let some mexicany woman who graduated at the top of her class but actually had to learn english while she did it (one must be born knowing how to speak english), on the supreme court we will have come one step closer shedding the xenophobia that our great melting pot of a country has always stood for.
racist, bigoted, overprivileged white men everywhere should come together now to blame everyone else for the problems they themselves have caused or there truly will be no justice.
Isn't the opposite of racism (reverse racism) the love of all people regardless of their race? "Reverse" commonly means the opposite of something. Rush obviously didn't think this one through. Now look how many bigots are following him. More "dittoheads" than I imagined. Did you see this on Rachel Maddow's show--"Ready, Fire, Aim." Perfect.
B*llshit! I am old enough to have lived through much of the same years that Pat Buchanan lived through and in the south. I lived through integration and segregation. I have seen the black water fountain and the white water fountain. I have gone to get a hamburger while my friend went to the back door to get his.
This non-sense about the poor downtrodden white man is complete bs. The angry white man, and I am white, is the bigot and the system they use is racism.
i thought the satire was obvious, if it wasn't, it is now.
They can dish it out, but they can't take it.
Nuff said.
Pat Buchanan, syndicated kook says: "blah, blah, blah............etc;
Hahahaha hehehehe bwahahaha..............
Oh shit, that was funny.
for each time he comments on cable, he could retire the national debt, bail out GM and Wall Street. Jesus, when does this man sleep?
Everytime I turn on my set, this cranky old bastard is explaining it all to me. Get the hook and get this guy off.
Login or Register to post comments.