Go Home

Panel Finds: Governor Sanford Broke The Law 37 Times

Get Adobe Flash player

DOWNLOADS: (1495)
Download WMV Download Quicktime
PLAYS: (1997)
Play WMV Play Quicktime
Embed

November 23, 2009 CNN

SANCHEZ: I want to start with some breaking news, Mark Sanford, embattled governor of South Carolina, accused today of breaking state laws, not one time, not two times, 37 times, according to the finding by the state ethics commission, 37 counts of law-breaking, which means Sanford's problems may transcend the political now, even as an impeachment committee is set to convene tomorrow.

You're going to recall the governor's problems began when he disappeared from view for something like five days last summer. It was a big story then, still is. Aides said that Sanford was -- quote -- "trying to clear his head" hiking along the Appalachian Trail.

But he was spotted then by a reporter getting off a flight from Argentina and then was forced to admit what we all now remember he ended up saying in a news conference, forced to admit to having a South American mistress at the time.

Since then, his wife has left him. She says the couple's separated. She is also writing a book about him. Any talk of a presidential run, forget about it, and now, on top of potential impeachment, 37 counts of breaking state law, much of it stemming from Sanford's frequent travels. Joining me now from Washington, CNN's Peter Hamby, who spent a lot of time chasing this story in South Carolina.

Look, we get the ethics thing. What I think you need to explain to us is how this becomes a criminal issue and specifically what crimes are we talking about.

PETER HAMBY: Well, what we're talking about here. And the ethics commission is not saying that he's actually broken a law yet. What they have found are 37 counts in this complaint that he may have violated state law by using his office for personal gain.

They list three different kinds of charges against him that they will argue in a hearing. They haven't set a hearing date yet, but they will soon. Many of those counts say that he upgraded from business class to coach on flights going back to 2005.

SANCHEZ: Sowhat? Is that a big -- who doesn't? Do you mean that they upgraded him or that he used money, public money, to do that?

HAMBY: Well, yes, exactly.

SANCHEZ: Is that what they mean?

HAMBY: Exactly. Exactly, that this was state business, that he used state money to upgrade.

SANCHEZ: Oh, OK. All right.

HAMBY: Right. Right. Right. So, he either -- the way that it's worded is, it says he used his official position for his own personal benefit by authorizing, approving and/or allowing the purchase of a business class ticket for himself on a flight from wherever to wherever.

SANCHEZ: OK.

HAMBY: It also accuses him or suggests that he used a state plane, state-owned plane to attend political functions around the state and the country and that he used campaign funds for his own personal gain.

SANCHEZ: So, the real deal here is not that he did what he did, which by any measure obviously looks like a foolish and just morally wrong thing to do. We all get that.

The real upshot here is the fact that he may have been using our money, I mean taxpayers' money, for this affair that he seemed to be having.

HAMBY: Exactly. And that's a big political headache for Mark Sanford. It's a big issue for him because his M.O. since coming to office and one of the reasons he was a rising national star in the Republican Party was that he was a champion of fiscal responsibility. And this whole fiasco for him, beyond the affair, these state legislators in South Carolina have seen him as a hypocrite in some respects, which is why a lot of them want him to resign and several are leading a charge to impeach him come January, when the session comes back...

(CROSSTALK)

SANCHEZ: And yet in many ways, when it comes to that measure, he is certainly not the first and most likely will not be the last in that regard.

Peter Hamby, great stuff. Thanks for bringing us up to date on this breaking story.

HAMBY: Sure.

SANCHEZ: Appreciate it.

HAMBY: Thanks, Rick.

Share This Post

Link To This Post


95 Comments
LewisB's picture
[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
Can O Whoopass's picture

Gay bashing Southern white christian hypocrites!

jay Severin Has A Small Pen1s's picture

I did not use public money to fly to Argentina to have sex with that woman.

roooth's picture

ask him, he'll tell you.

Besides, God wanted him to do it.

and with a conservative republican
AG, i will be very surprised that
he receives any punishment or
reprimand for his criminal actions.

For Sanford to still be still standing as Governor and preaching the word of God after all he's done tells you everything you need to know about the South.

Kentucky just topped off how corrupt and evil they've become by officially ruling the Federal census taker's death as a suicide.

Bush and Cheney's legacy will ultimately be their empowering of all that is evil in and of America.

Bokonon's picture

and it has possessed the Republican Party. They have hypocritically taken the name of Jesus in vain while opposing everything Jesus stood for.

They'll be mighty surprised when they learn that Paul's Get-out-of-Hell-free card is worthless without good works.

Homosexual or not, they will all burn in Hell.

savannah43's picture

Jesus plus nothing. The rallying cry of C Streeters. Sanford is one of the ordained, and thus exempt from all laws, both civil and religious. Just ask him, or any other member of The Family.

Liberal AND Proud's picture

SANCHEZ: So, the real deal here is not that he did what he did, which by any measure obviously looks like a foolish and just morally wrong thing to do. We all get that.

"When the governor does it, it's not illegal", besides everyone does it.

30 years and the GOP still can't come up with new excuses to justify their criminal behavior.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

Having an affair is not illegal, nor is hypocrisy (and they shouldn't be). It sure is gunna be hard for him to run another election campaign on "family values" though.

His state could impeach him on the grounds of idiocy, but as for the plane tickets - he could just pay SC back.

Liberalicious's picture

and not telling a soul about it?

Ordinary peons usually get fired for crap like that. That's what the impeachment panel is supposed to be looking at.

Again, not illegal, but a possible dereliction. For this he could also be impeached.

Liberalicious's picture

why is that?

Because the story here is not the few-thousand dollars he misappropriated from SC. I don’t care about his affair, and I don’t care that much about his flight-seating. The penalty for him for his upgrades is to pay the money back.

The story is his hypocrisy, and that he got caught. Also that there is now no chance in hell that he will be reelected.

Liberalicious's picture

What part of "broke the LAW 37 times" don't you understand?

I don't give a flip about the sex either, but he abandoned his duty and BROKE THE LAW. I think that means he's a criminal too.

There’s probably much I don’t understand about the 37 ethics violations. I do know that 18 of them were for upgrades when the state says he must fly coach. I do know that 10 of them were for improper reimbursements from campaign funds for personal expenses amounting to 2K or so. Don’t know much else – but I would love to see other Govs scrutinized this closely. I’m sure most would fail the same test.

If you wish to use these counts as an indication that he was corrupt – have at it. But take care. Your most trusted and supported politician may fall to the same scrutiny. In this age of multi-million dollar campaigns, it’s easy to overlook, and abuse.

But again, these few thousand dollars of misappropriations are not why SC and the rest of the country are looking so closely at Sanford. They found these violations when they began to look at him for reasons of impeachment. SC seems to want him impeached for his lying and his affair. That’s fine with me, but if this is all they have to get him on, it’s pretty weak.

ricky's picture

its all about the rule of law.

Where is Linda Tripp when we need her? Whatever happened to Jennifer Flowers? Did Willy threaten Kathleen Willey? Why wouldn't a nice round of golf at Myrtle Beach suffice?

These questions must be answered if we are to remain a nation that respects the rule of law.
Even if he shot some old man in the face!


"The deal has to be negotiated in the real world, not on some idealized Aristotelian plane. We understand that. A 100-percent deal may be impossible."
Famous "Reality Based" Commentator

Liberalicious's picture

They put Al Capone in Alcatraz for tax evasion. So don't cry "pretty weak" to me.

As for other political figures having careers ruined because of criminal investigations, we'll I'm all for it, don't care which side of the political fence they are on, if they BROKE THE LAW, then too effing bad. If they had focused more on the lying under oath for Clinton than the blow job, they may have got the impeachment through.

What I don't understand it why you are so willing to forgive his misuse of public funds, a breach of the public's trust? I suppose since it wasn't your money, you don't care.

If you break the law, you have to pay for it if you get caught. Rep of Dem it does not matter.

ricky's picture

Argentina. or Tina Fey for that matter.


"The deal has to be negotiated in the real world, not on some idealized Aristotelian plane. We understand that. A 100-percent deal may be impossible."
Famous "Reality Based" Commentator

Liberalicious's picture

for America.

Not forgive, Liberalicious - not even tolerate. It's just my outrage I reserve for more outrageous political acts, of which there are plenty.

Liberalicious's picture

to bring down corrupt political officials, I'm all for it. Because apparently starting wars under false pretenses, killing and torturing loads and load of people, illegally spying on people, etc, doesn't seem to warrant a mote of consideration anymore.

The Sailor's picture

"SECTION 16-15-60. Adultery or fornication.

Any man or woman who shall be guilty of the crime of adultery or fornication shall be liable to indictment and, on conviction, shall be severally punished by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisonment for not less than six months nor more than one year or by both fine and imprisonment, at the discretion of the court."

Thanks Sailor. I guess we are talking about South Carolina...

The Sailor's picture

Yes, SC

Liberal AND Proud's picture

I visited my girlfriend in Atlanta last weekend.

When we finally unraveled ourselves, she turned to me and said, "Half the things we just did, are illegal in this state".

Of course, my answer was..."Only half, hmmm...we're not workin' hard enuf."


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

pissed off patricia's picture

"Adultery or fornication"? Okay I admit I don't know much about these subjects, but aren't they the same thing. I know adultery is messing around on your husband or wife, but if you did that wouldn't it mean you had "fornicated"?


Say what you mean. Mean what you say. But don't say it mean.

savannah43's picture

unindoctrinated in the ways of sex (priests) speak of it. You know that saying that goes something like this, "If you can't wow them with facts, then baffle them with bullshit?" That's the religious right's battle cry.

luis stoole's picture

but what if he did it in another country on another continent?

and if he does get sent to jail, how does the whole conjugal visit work out?
will he have to wait for the divorce papers to clear first?

ricky's picture

made him do it?


"The deal has to be negotiated in the real world, not on some idealized Aristotelian plane. We understand that. A 100-percent deal may be impossible."
Famous "Reality Based" Commentator

luis stoole's picture

because the chemicals in his spray on tan have been shown to be neurotoxic in clinical studies, some confusing and erratic behavior were definitely beyond his control.

ricky's picture

with thong tan lines after his trip? It is almost as shocking as the 37 major crimes committed here.


"The deal has to be negotiated in the real world, not on some idealized Aristotelian plane. We understand that. A 100-percent deal may be impossible."
Famous "Reality Based" Commentator

luis stoole's picture

public deserves to know

Liberal AND Proud's picture

I really couldn't care less who or what he sleeps with.

It appears that he used public funds for his little rendevous'.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

That does take hutzpah. Really, most of these offenses were for upgrades. I have trouble getting bent out of shape over that. Personally, I think the guy is nutz for the way he skipped town and paid for his extra-marital trists. But also, on a scale of previous political scandals - he's a lightweight.

Liberal AND Proud's picture

I have trouble getting bent out of shape over that...on a scale of previous political scandals - he's a lightweight.

Yeah...it's not like he killed anyone.

*snark off*


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

liberalNmoderation's picture

surely they have more on him than this crap.
O'Donnell summed it up quite well on TRMS last night.

bushputz's picture

When Republicans start calling you a hypocrite, you've made it to the big leagues...

Liberalicious's picture

Isn't that rather hypocritical?

;)

liberalNmoderation's picture

but I'm sayin "hypocrite" one more time anyway.

Samson-'s picture

he has so many "counts of law-breaking" that they have to seperate them into groups?

...should break out singing Percy Sledge's 1966 classic "When a man loves a woman"

Loving eyes can never see.

Handypants's picture
...

Sanford and his odd actions were far FAR worse than anything Bubba did.

Sanford was off the wall and out of touch. I think it was a breakdown of sorts. Those weird days should have been the end of his political career.


"I know that there are people who do not love their fellow
man, and I hate people like that!
" ~ Tom Lehrer (1928 - )

Evet's picture

Rod Blagojevich will appear on Season 9 of The Celebrity Apprentice in Spring 2010 and wants to jump on the gravy train.

Liberalicious's picture

"Dancing with the Stars" would be more his forte.

Liberalicious's picture

"Lifetime" will get a semi-decent flick out of it.

taller ghost walt's picture

Valerie Bertinelli?

pissed off patricia's picture

More like Hoofing with the Has-beens.


Say what you mean. Mean what you say. But don't say it mean.

right on_exclamation point here's picture

that's great... thanks for the laughs!!

Liberalicious's picture

is composed of 3 Dems and 4 Rethugs.

See if you can guess what will happen.

liberalNmoderation's picture

Or am I thinkin of some OTHER case of nepotism amongst the right?

Handypants's picture
...

I heard democrats and republicans in SC are not the same as your generic D & R.

So much crazy stuff comes from SC - maybe they'll end up giving him some kind of an award?

Seriously, nothing would surprise me these days.


"I know that there are people who do not love their fellow
man, and I hate people like that!
" ~ Tom Lehrer (1928 - )

I woulda thunk at least 69.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Liberal AND Proud's picture

68...and like a typical conservative he'll owe her one.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Wouldn't that be more like 34.5

And she didn't get her half?


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Liberal AND Proud's picture

Either way, she's not satisfied. But then again, for conservatives it's all about a woman's place....


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

Liberalicious's picture

that conservatives didn't want women to have rights to their "place".

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Samson-'s picture

another black eye for The Family

Medical Diagnosis by Video's picture

A Republican thief and hypocrite? That's news?

Hardly. It is SOP.

MountainMan23's picture

From ABC NightLine, by way of MoxNews at YouTube:

BYE! BYE! SENATOR ENSIGN! pt.1

BYE! BYE! SENATOR ENSIGN! pt.2

But .. is it really "Bye! Bye!" ???

And note that Coburn's got his privates caught in the wringer too! And he's up for re-election in 2010! hmmm ..


Democracy is too important to be entrusted to politicians.
Rise Up!
Protest!

Liberal AND Proud's picture

And note that Coburn's got his privates caught in the wringer

Ok...next time...please comment a bit more delicately. I'm still having aftershocks from that image. Yeeouch!


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

There once was a man named Winger
Who got his balls caught in a wringer
He said with some pain
As they rolled down the drain
(falsetto) "There goes my career as a singer!"

no longer a proud american's picture

what did they call gotti, the silicone don...nothing stuck. so i'll believe it when the guy is behind bars in a real prison.

George W. Gump's picture

I believe they called him the Teflon Don. But silicon is funnier. I'm sure there's a joke in there somewhere.

Limp-Dick Blimpaugh's picture

I'm shocked about another Reslug criminal!!

right on_exclamation point here's picture

I'm guessing charges are going to be laid and he'll get a trial, and hopefully find himself in jail. Right?!

Liberal AND Proud's picture

I'm guessing charges are going to be laid

Geez, this guy will sleep with anything!....except his wife of course.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

right on_exclamation point here's picture

Hah hah!!

DamOTclese's picture

When Christian Republicans commit crimes against us, they usually go all out. And Clinton was impeached for a blow job. Where's the rightarded loons screaming about this scumbag?

Sanford is not a Dem. That's all there is to it.

deal, Sanchez, you DORK.

He's not spending his own money. He's spending the taxpayers' money, and he doesn't need to be in business class. He should be flying cheaply and rarely. Where does he need to go, anyway? He's a governor. He should be working on state business.

Are there policies in place about how you can travel? There have been in every company I've worked for, and upgrading your tickets or rental cars on the company dime is verboten.

ohkay's picture

Catch the related discussion on today's "Fresh Air" with Terri Gross, she interviews Jeff Sharlet, about his new book on The 'C' Street Family.

"The Family: The Secret Fundamentalism at the Heart of American Power."

cultists

infiltrators


"Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob"
-= Franklin Delano Roosevelt =-

Liberal AND Proud's picture

Read it. Recommend it.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

luis stoole's picture

more trees will have to die for another stupid book

pissed off patricia's picture

Probably the only difference between Sanford and his republican buddies is that he got caught "hiking".


Say what you mean. Mean what you say. But don't say it mean.

It's up to the residents of South Carolina to decide what they want to put up with. Breaking 37 laws doesn't amount to a hill of beans if there are not consequences for his actions.

Hell, the husband of Ensign's mistress said he has not been contacted by the Department of Justice about any investigation into the fraud and distortion allegations being made.

Obviously none of you were listening when Sanford was talking about his "Soul mate". This wasn't just some Hoe-bag.That's why he's not guilty.

Mr. Sanford explains:
In emotional interviews with the AP over two days, he said he would die "knowing that I had met my soul mate." He also said he had "crossed the lines" with a handful of other women during 20 years of marriage, but not as far as he did with his mistress.
And he didn't dump in a diaper for his "Soul mate" like David "Baby made a Boom Boom" Vitter. Jeez everybody lighten up,already.

Liberal AND Proud's picture

he said he would die "knowing that I had met my soul mate."

And when is he going to fulfill that political promise?


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

bibimimi's picture

but if he'd gone all the way there and didn't 'get some' he'd look like a complete tool.

Floridiot's picture

feeling the Argentine woman is covering up for the man in his life

George W. Gump's picture

Nah. Sanford seems more the womanizing type to me. Either way, IOKIYAR.

MinuteMan's picture

You have to wonder about ex-governor Palin and soon-to-be-ex-governor Sanford: they're both koolaid swilling GOPers but both had their GOP legislatures calling for their heads. Maybe the guvs are a bit hard to get a long with?

Miss Argentina on a map? And if she could, wouldn't we still want Maqrk Sanford to just take a hike?


"The deal has to be negotiated in the real world, not on some idealized Aristotelian plane. We understand that. A 100-percent deal may be impossible."
Famous "Reality Based" Commentator

bibimimi's picture

the Argentina and such...

Clinton didn't leave the country to schtup Monica AND NOT TELL ANYONE WHERE HE WAS GOING. It's unlikely a Democrat would ever take the presidency again if that were the case. Something like this puts a blot on the whole party...this is where the Tea Party steps in and claims the mantle of responsible government whether deserved or not.

Thanks, Sanford. UR an amazing piece of......work.

Midtown Maniac's picture

The reporter went out of his way to say the panel found the governor MAY HAVE broken the law etc.. I don't like Sanford and his politics but let's have some integrity ourselves.. we can't demand integrity if we don't value it for ourselves.. Oh.. ohohoh, OK, he's worse and we're just bad.. which makes us better? we can certainly be better.. like Clinton was better than Bush though both were bad, Bush just worse.. and after Bush, Obama can do anything cuz no one could be as bad as Bush? I want more than not as bad..

randcamp's picture

From the reporter interviewed by Sanchez:

And the ethics commission is not saying that he's actually broken a law yet. What they have found are 37 counts in this complaint that he may have violated state law by using his office for personal gain.

It's not necessary, in this profligate example, to embellish the facts.

This is what happens when you let a C-Street cultist represent you.


"Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob"
-= Franklin Delano Roosevelt =-

oh really's picture

I think Sanford should have resigned when this story broke. Since he refused to resign, I think he should be fired, recalled, or impeached and removed from office -- whichever is the most appropriate means of accomplishing the end of terminating his tenure as governor.

That said, the C&L headline says Sanford had been found to have broken laws, while the text of the interview says that the panel has concluded that he "may" have violated laws. I don't think Sanford needs to have broken any laws to warrant removal from office, but neither do I think C&L should be reporting something that has not yet been determined.

If CSPANJunkie or anyone else wants to offer an opinion that Sanford is guilty and here's why, I have no problem with that. I do have a problem with misrepresenting the findings of a panel.

project's picture

Duke cunningham, neigh, everyone connected with the bush cabal.
Hell republicans live to steal its the only reason they got into government to start with.
republicanism/conservatism is a mental illness that is killing America!

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Tax the Rich's picture

Come on guys. All he needs to do, is sit in a kum-bay-ya circle with Ensign, Vitter and Coburn, profess his love forbjeebus, and everything should be forgotten.


Rush Limbaugh is what a smart person thinks a stupid bigot sounds like.

Comments are closed on this entry